Reviewers’ Guidelines 

Introduction

The role of a reviewer is very important to the quality of the materials we publish. The reviewer provides an independent unbiased recommendation that assist the author to improve the quality of the paper and the editor to make an informed judgement whether to accept and publish a paper or not.

As a reviewer, please ensure your expertise and time are directed towards the manuscript you have accepted for review.

Review reports

Please provide score on a scale 1-10 for the following assessment area:

• Originality
• Contribution to the field
• Technical quality
• Clarity of presentation
• Depth of research

Recommendations

Reviewers’ recommendation should be either:

• Accept
• Accept after revision
• Revise and resubmit for review
• Reject